We chose to do the day trip rather than the overnight trip, if I could pick again know what I know now I would go for two nights! It's out of the way for just one night, feels like a lot of effort I think but if you have time for two I think it would be incredible. The day trip allowed enough time to go straight in to hours of snorkelling after the transfer. Watching the fish was amazing and it's worth having a guide point a few spots out. We went to two spots, the first for Fisk and the second for the coral - both great. When we then got to the island for a late lunch it was very peaceful and the food was tasty, top points for the battered bananas. The sand is perfect and the sea was calm for us, a paradise beach. I would go back!